Katz Korner: DVDs, Blu-rays, and Collecting… What Do You Prefer?

I figured it was about time to start another little feature on the blog to get some good conversations flowing. Thus, in place of Follow Friday, I will be doing a weekly Friday Discussion, now called Katz Korner, where I pose a question (or two) to all of you readers relating to movies and what not. Shall we begin?

When it comes to DVDs and Blu-rays, how big is your collection? Is it something you’re proud of or ashamed of?

My own collection is at about 1,000 right now, but I’m really wanting to downsize. There’s simply too many films in the library that I picked up here and there (usually dirt cheap) and have since regretted owning them or have grown tired of their presence, like an old toy that’s past its use. Yeah, I just got a little depressing.

However, it’s still something I’m really proud of. In college, I was known as the movie guy and would rent out DVDs and be the go to for a recommendation or two. Sadly, lending out so many resulted in me losing a few of my favorites (Criterions went missing, not cool!). Regardless, my movie library has become my baby and I’m proud to show it off when I can. Now I just need a sexy apartment or something, with a badass way to display them.

Have you found yourself buying the same films you own on DVD on Blu-ray, in hopes of upgrading your collecting?

Perhaps the biggest issue I have with my collection is the DVD to Blu-ray ratio. I demand high definition, dammit! With the advent of Blu-rays and high definition, I’ve realize how spoiled I have gotten. So many DVDs I have now just look terrible in comparison and I now only want the best. Which of course, means trading in DVDs for scraps, selling stuff for cash, or finding other ways to upgrade the collection. Again, this doesn’t come easy. There are a few sites (like Music Magpie) that let you trade stuff in for other movies, CDs, and games, and I think it’s about time I crack down on my collection and decide which of my babies need to get “adopted” by someone else.

In this digital age, have you come to prefer digital content over hard-copies, or is still owning a physical version of the film your biggest preference?

Netflix. Hulu. Amazon. UltraViolet. Flixster. There are thousands and thousands of movies available for digital download and streaming all thanks to the wonderful internet. While it’s a convenience, I personally am worried that my physical collection will slowly become irrelevant as the digital age takes over. I’d much rather own actual copies of movies when I shuck out cash. I don’t want to throw down $100 and have eight movies sitting in an account online that I can access whenever I want. I want to pull that beautiful Blu-ray, in it’s slip cover, off of the shelf and pop it in the player instead. Why spend money on something you can’t show off, right?

Written By Nick

Nick is a man obsessed with all things related to film. From the most obscure to the very popular, he’s seen it all and hopes to one day turn his obsession into a career that makes a lot of money so he can buy a monkey, a bulldog, and a full size Batman suit.

29 Readers Commented

Join discussion
  1. Fogs' Movie Reviews on February 15, 2013
    I do collect... I started with DVD back in the day, then shifted to HD (HD DVDs first). Now my collection is about 1,000? 1,200? With 450 High Def titles and about half of my DVD collection still on hand. It takes up an entire wall of my living room!
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      Beautiful. Feel free to show it off if you have any pictures! I love feeling jealous (and then immediately spend way too much of my own money in a frugal attempt to catch up to you).
  2. Your post reminded us that we need to post an article we've been meaning to post where we show our movie collection and the rest of the (modest) Man Cave in our apartment. Speaking of modest, you're collection would dwarf ours if yours is truly 1000 strong, lol To answer your questions, only on rare occasions do we buy a Blu-ray copy of a movie we already own on DVD, and that's primarily if the movie is one we love and decide we definitely need in HD. Like STAR TREK or THE DARK KNIGHT. And to answer your last question while also staying with the previous example, we always buy the physical copy of a movie. If possible we buy the Blu-ray/DVD combo pack, and more importantly, if possible, we try to get the Blu-ray/DVD/Digital combo pack because while we definitely NEED the physical copy for our collection, we realize the convenience of having films right on our laptops (and future iPad). We're of the belief that physical copies will never go away because there will always be a market for wanting and/or needing the physical copy. Not everyone has the capabilities of watching a movie digitally, nor do a lot of people want to. We also love having the physical disc to hold and put into the player, to let people borrow and to move with us when going places. We'd rather not have our entire collection on a server somewhere or on a hard-drive that could get compromised.
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      You make a good point. I don't think digital will overtake physical until EVERYONE has sexy fast internet. Of course, I'm an advocate of everyone having such a thing, but if it means me losing my physical copies of things, I may have to say f**k it and let the rural areas suffer at the hands of satelitte and dial up! mwahahahahhaa
  3. Two Tickets For... on February 15, 2013
    We collect too. There is just something better about being able to pull a movie off the shelf. We are actually planning on doing a little show and tell on our collection. We are still in the process of changing some of our favorites over to Blu-rays which usually results in 3 versions of the same movie...ah the joys of merging collections!
    • See, Nick? We were on the same page without even talking about it, lol
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      I can assume you alphabetize like crazy then as well? I may have to show mine off soon.
  4. Tyson Carter on February 15, 2013
    All about collecting, why have them stored digitally somewhere?! Got to be displayed for sure!! :) I own over 1000 dvd's, and slowly building a blu ray collection. I'm lucky in that my wife lets me have a 'man cave' in the house but even now i'm running out of room. And proud of it, definitely! :P
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      Haha. I think most movies are allowed in a "man cave" or trigger the creation of one because everyone loves movies. And as you're a blogger as well, if your wife doesn't approve of such a thing, you have certainly married the long woman.
  5. filmhipster on February 15, 2013
    They still make DVD's? I'm a Blu-ray junkie. I have about 400 right now and if it wasn't for my wife it would be double that.
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      Nice. Any super special editions or anything so awesome you have to brag about?
      • filmhipster on February 15, 2013
        Um, I adore my copy of Band of Brothers, steal case. The Star Wars collection rocks!! Nothing really too special though. You?
        • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
          Special edition Batpod of The Dark Knight. A cool Iron Man mask special edition Blu-ray. And a signed copy of Sleepwalk with Me lol. That's it
          • filmhipster on February 15, 2013
            Ohhhhh....I'm very jealous! I've seen the Iron Man mask. But a signed copy of Sleepwalk with Me? Love that film.
            • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
              Yeah! If you preordered it on Birbiglia's website, he personally signed the copy for you. Only like $28 too!
              • filmhipster on February 15, 2013
                Amazing. My most prized film possession I have is a signed 'If Chins Could Kill: Confessions of a B Movie Actor' by Bruce Campbell.
  6. Lindsey on February 15, 2013
    I collect DVD, blu and VHS, but mostly DVDs. My collection ins't enormous (three shelves) but I own a lot of box sets, so the actual number of films I own is pretty high (around 600). I'm not big on digital copies, and as much as I enjoy streaming I will also buy a film on DVD even if it's already available at my fingertips on Netflix!
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      VHS collector? Oh boy! lol. Yeah, box sets secretly boost up collection numbers. I have a few and I like to count each individual film as part of the whole collection. As much as it is about quality, quantity always has its weight.
      • Lindsey on February 15, 2013
        My VHS collection isn't huge but my local Goodwill has a ridiculously good selection (I once found 3 copies of My Man Godfrey there, still in the shrinkwrap!). I always get roped into buying odd finds there, and my VHS player from childhood is still operational :)
  7. Ryan on February 15, 2013
    I had a ton of DVD's but since blu-rays came out I havn't bought a single DVD. I actually kind of hide them now as I upgrade. I don't buy everything I see either just to "have a big collection", I only buy movies that I genuinely love.
    • Nick Author on February 15, 2013
      Most of my DVDs just sit in binders now anyway. Blu-rays are all out on display though!
  8. Daniel Prinn on February 15, 2013
    I try to get those awesome Blu-ray combo packs, but for me, if I don't have it and if it's just a comedy, it isn't the end of the world. In my own collection, I probably have 350 DVDs and Blu-Rays (maybe 60 Blu-Rays). I started last January, so it's slowly building... I'm very proud of it, but I'd like to downsize and get rid of some films I don't really like. Like some of the Omen films. Second and third sequels are just awful. One of the coolest new things I own is this Cabin in the Woods Visual Companion. Okay, okay. It's a book - but it's fucking awesome. And I adore my Blu-ray copy of Cabin. Seriously though, Nick, I know you're a fan of the film - so if you don't already have the Visual Companion, I'd recommend buying it. Wicked cool.
    • Nick Author on February 16, 2013
      I need to check it out. Sounds like it would be interesting. Does it have like monster designs and stuff?
      • Daniel Prinn on February 16, 2013
        Yeah, there's a twenty-page Creature Feature (Making the Monsters). The book has the screenplay, an interview with Goddard and Whedon on making the film, other interviews, behind the scenes secrets, production art. There's so much to go through, lol. I'm not sure how alike it is to the special features on the Blu-ray because I haven't gone through that yet, but I'm hoping to find info on that Kevin "monster" lol. I got it on my Amazon.ca for $16.57, but it's on .com for $13.57.
  9. Joe Giuliano on February 15, 2013
    I'm going to have to take pictures real soon of my collection. I used to have a fairly accurate idea of how many movies (DVDs, Blu-rays, VHS) were in my collection, but I've honestly lost count. I'm pretty sure it's somewhere around 15K, but it's probably closer to 10K. I've got all but a few collections (Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Band of Brothers, The Pacific, Scarface Steelbook, Green Lantern Steelbook, Lord of the Rings Extended Editions, and few others) in binders and on spindles. I do am the local rental store Nick. I've got a few buddies that come do an exchange every 2-3 months. For the most part, I don't think I've ever had something not returned. Actually, I'm the guy the give their movies to when they decide they don't want them anymore.
    • Nick Author on February 16, 2013
      Haha. Well lucky for you. I've lost a few favorites being nice. Yet again, that was college. You're an old man so your peers have a bit of integrity lol.
  10. Trevor on February 16, 2013
    This is a great topic for discussion and something that I've starting to have to come to terms with. Basically the cloud kicks the crap out of having a phycial collection. Everything's at your fingertips and in the case of Netflix and Amazon it's much cheaper. That being said there's something about going through a physical collection rather than flipping through an online system. There's also more security in owning something physical rather than buying into a cloud system that, when it goes under or stops existing you lose your entire collection. But Netflix streaming does sometimes get product that is simply unavailable in disc form. Right now I'm stuck in between having both a physical and a cloud collection. Someday they'll get their act together and we'll all be going into the clouds for our movies, most people already watch most of their content that way at this point anyhow.
    • Nick Author on February 16, 2013
      I'm fine with streaming per subscription, I just want a physical copy of entire films I purchase. If digital copies continue to go down, however, that will be a big deciding factor for me. And as much as streaming is convenient, a shoddy internet means you can't watch anything.
  11. 70srichard on February 17, 2013
    Streaming does not let your houseguests browse thru and comment on your collection and taste. I have over a 1000 DVDs and I am close to 200 blue ray despite my reluctance to repurchase and upgrade everything. Also, until I have a restored working laser disc player, I have refrained from buying more from that dead media. The near 800 12 inch discs are still in the house, proudly displayed on magazine racks I acquired for that purpose. The giant covers are often more interesting than the contents.

Have something to say?