Pick Six: Movies that are better on DVD than Blu-Ray

By now we are all aware of how awesome movies look on Blu-ray, especially if you own a 1080p high definition television. I still own a VHS and a Laserdisc player and it’s still fun to go back and see how the quality changes from one  format to another. When DVDs first came out the image and sound was incredible. I remember watching Long Kiss Goodnight and being so impressed with the action I thought nothing would ever come close to this. I thought this way for a long time until I caught a clip of Blazing Saddles on Blu-ray. The movie was over 2o years old, but it looks like it was made just last year. It looked so smooth I thought I was watching a home movie about the production of it. It was that clear.

Since Blu-ray has become more popular I have seen many movies make their way from one format to the other.  Yes the visuals are improved, but all the cool special features that were on the DVD are not included. It’s weird because Blu-rays hold a lot more information than DVD. I guess they had to give up a few features to give it that crisp look, but I wanted those features transported over. These next six titles are ones that remain better on DVD then they do on Blu-ray.

Escape from New York. 1981

displaymedia.php

John Carpenter’s  tale of a dystopian future  about a city that becomes a prison and one man’s attempt to rescue the president was giving a good 25 anniversary edition DVD. None of the features were included on the Blu-ray.  In fact  it even comes with a DVD but doesn’t have any of the features that this one has.

The Special features included

* Audio commentary with Kurt Russell and John Carpenter.

* deleted opening sequence with optional commentary from Russell and Carpenter

*  ”Return to Escape From New York”   A brand new featurette about the making of the movie

* Making of the comic “Snake Plisken Chronicles”

* The actual preview comic of “Snake Plisken Chronicles

Robocop  1987

23_box_348x490

There are two versions of Paul Verhoeven’s brutal but funny science fiction film about a cop who comes back as a cyborg after he is killed.   One is a Criterion edition DVD and the other is a 20th anniversary DVD.  Neither of these features are on the Blu-ray.  It doesn’t even have any trailers, it just has the uncut version and that’s it.

Criterion Edition.

*  The Unrated Director’s cut

*Audio Commentary from Director Paul Verhoeven,Cowriter Edward Neumier, Executive Producer Jon Davison, and Robocop expert Paul M Sammon.

*Storyboard to film comparison

*Storyboards

*An illustrated essay on the making of Robocop

*Theatrical and Teaser Trailers

20th Aniversary DVD

Disc one.

*Theatrical Version.

*Audio Commentary by Verhoeven, Neumier, and Davison

* Flesh and Steel Documentary

* 2 Featurettes

* Storyboards with commentary by Phill Tippet.

*  Deleted Scenes

* Photo Gallery

* Trailers and TV Spots.

Disc 2.

* The Unrated Director’s Cut.

*  The villains of Robocop

* Special Effects

* Then and Now. Robocop creating a legend

The Thing.  1982

thethingcarpenterDVD699

Another John Carpenter Classic about a group of scientists who have to battle a creature who can become anything it touches.  The movie had a lot of groundbreaking practical effects at the time and the DVD covers that with some good features.  None of it are on the Blu-ray.

Special Features

*Audio Commentary by John Carpenter and Kurt Russell

* 80 minute documentary

* Stop motion animation that was cut from the film

*Production background archives.

* Cast Production Photos

* Production art and storyboards

*Location Design

* The Blairmonster

*The Saucer

* Outtakes

*Post Production

*Theatrical Trailer

*Production Notes

Dawn of The Dead.   1978

0001313121679_500X500

When Zack  Snyder’s remake came out in 2004.  Anchor Bay released this ultimate edition gift set that included all three versions of this movie.  Sadly The Blu-ray only included the theatrical version and a few of the special features.

Special Features.

Disc one.

*Theatrical Cut.

*Audio Commentary by the filmmakers George Romero, Tom Savini, and Chris Romero

*TV and Radio Spots.

*Poster and Advertising Gallery

*George Romero Bio

* Comic Book Preview

Disc two

*Extended Edition

*Audio Commentary by Producer Richard P. Rubenstien

*Monroeville Mall commercial

* Behind the scenes photo gallery

* Memorabilia gallery

* Production stills

Disc 3.

*European Version

*Audio Commentary by the 4 main actors: David Emgee, Gaylen Ross, Ken Foree,  and Scott H. Reinger

* International Theatrical Trailers

* U.K. TV Spots

* International Lobby Card Gallery

* International  Poster Gallery

* International Press book Gallery

* Home video and soundtrack artwork

* Dario Argento Bio

Disc 4

“Document Of The Dead”  - A feature-length documentary made during the production of “Dawn of the Dead“.

“The Dead Will Walk” – A brand new documentary featuring new interviews with the cast and crew.

* A  Tour of the Monroeville Mall with Ken Foree

*Onset home movies with zombie extra Robert Langer (The one on the escalator)

Silence Of The Lambs.  1991

13_box_348x490

The only horror( Yes, Horror) movie  to win the Oscar for best picture in 1991.  There were two really cool editions of this classic on DVD, but none of the features on either version were ported over to the Blu-ray.

Criterion Edition

*Audio Commentary  by director Johnathan Demme, actors Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins,  screenwriter Ted Talley, and FBI Agent – John Douglas

* Seven Deleted Scenes

* Film to storyboard comparisons

* Storyboards

*FBI crime classification manual

*  ”Voices of Death” – Actual word of mouth statements of actual serial killers

Special Edition

* A 60 minute documentary that looks back on the production of the film

* A ten minute  featurette  that was made at the same time of this movie

* Outtakes

* Phone Message by Hannibal Lecter

* Deleted Scenes

*Theatrical Trailers and TV Spots.

American Psycho. 2000

rN9Za

Mary Harron’s film version of Bret Easton Ellis satire of the American Male was not highly regarded when it first came out but has since become a classic.  The Blu-ray does port over a lot of cool features from the DVD but it left out a really cool Documentary that discussed the book and the production of the movie

Killer Collectors Edition

*Audio Commentary with director Mary Harron

*Audio Commentary with Co Writer Guinevere Turner

*From Book to Screen

*The 80′s Downtown

*Deleted Scenes with optional commentary

*The pornography of killing – A video essay by Holly Willis

Written By The Vern

Yes Hello people. It is I The Vern. Lover of movies, women, and whiskey, but not in that particular order. Besides writing for this site. I help co host The As You Watch podcast and help contribute to the world of films wherever I can.

5 Readers Commented

Join discussion
  1. The Warriors immediately comes to mind with Walter Hill's re-edit. My Blu-ray collection is still quite small so I'll make sure I stay clear of these. Nice list, Vern.
    • The Vern on February 9, 2013
      Nice inclusion of warriors Ben. I forgot al about that flick. Have not seen the director's version but will look for it. Thanks.
  2. Pat McD on February 9, 2013
    Nice list. My brain went a different direction as I read. There are certain films that I associate with a different era of film and Bluray actually makes these look almost too clean. Sometimes it highlights imperfections a lower res masked. Other times, I'm just so used to the crackle of an old video tape that a clean copy is distracting. Obviously, this applies to older films but even newer films like Super 8 and Cloverfield can stand to be a little imperfect. Sometimes it's less important for a presentation to be perfect. It's better for it to look "right."
    • The Vern on February 9, 2013
      Thank you Pat. I still own a bunch of movies on Laserdisk including the Original Star Wars Trilogy. There is no way Im getting rid of that. I agree that soe movies can look a bit too clean. "Blazing Saddles" on Blueray comes to mind. That looks like Im watching a home movie . It's that clean.
  3. Vivek on February 9, 2013
    Godfather is also better. Blu Ray fucks up the grit way way too much.

Have something to say?